Concussion education / St. Petersburg & Clearwater / For attorneys

A Broken Wrist and a Missed Concussion: Distracting Injuries in Pinellas Crash Files

When a crash client arrives at the ER with a broken wrist or shoulder, the fracture tends to lead the chart. Research shows a concussion in the same patient is often never written down, and that changes how early records in Sixth Circuit files should be read.

Who this is for: Written for personal injury attorneys, paralegals and case managers in St. Petersburg, Clearwater and the rest of Pinellas County whose crash clients came out of the ER with a fracture or other obvious injury and a chart that says little about the head.

A client is rear-ended in stop-and-go traffic on the Howard Frankland Bridge and braces against the steering wheel. The ER splints a broken wrist and sends him home. Three weeks later, he tells his paralegal that he keeps losing track of conversations at work. Another client, hit while turning at a busy US-19 intersection, has a shoulder fracture and a discharge sheet that never mentions her head. These are hypothetical examples.

In both files, the injury that showed up on an X-ray is well documented. The possible concussion is not. This article explains why that happens and what tends to make a record easier to follow. It is educational and is not legal or medical advice.

Key takeaways

  • In one study, 56% of ER patients who met the CDC definition of mild TBI had no mild TBI-related diagnosis in the ER record.
  • Among 251 limb-fracture patients, interviews found mild TBI in 23.5%, while hospital records showed it in 8.8%.
  • A concussion can follow a hit to the body, so a fracture from bracing or impact is a reason to ask about the head.
  • Pinellas County recorded 14,391 crashes and 8,804 injuries in 2024 (FLHSMV).

What the research shows

In a study at two emergency departments, a Level I trauma center and an academic hospital, researchers identified 197 patients who met the CDC definition of mild TBI. Fifty-six percent of them had no mild TBI-related diagnosis documented in the ER record. The largest gap was for confusion, noted by study staff in 94% of cases but in 28% of ER records (Powell, 2008).

A second study looked at 251 patients treated for a single limb fracture at the orthopedic clinic of a Level I trauma hospital in Montreal. Structured interviews identified a mild TBI at the time of the fracture in 23.5% of patients, while hospital records showed one in 8.8%. Patients with upper limb fractures were more likely to have had a mild TBI than those with lower limb fractures, 29.6% compared with 15.6% (Jodoin, 2016). Both studies were done at single centers and included injuries from many causes, not only car crashes.

56%of ED patients meeting CDC mild TBI criteria had no mild TBI-related diagnosis in the ER record (Powell, 2008)
23.5% vs 8.8%mild TBI found by interview versus in hospital records among 251 limb-fracture patients (Jodoin, 2016)

Why a concussion can hide behind a fracture

  • The CDC notes that a concussion can follow a hit to the body that moves the head quickly back and forth, so a direct blow to the head is not required.
  • The CDC also notes that a person may not recognize or admit problems, and that symptoms can be overlooked by the person, the family or the healthcare provider.
  • Some symptoms may not appear for hours or days, after the ER visit is over.
  • Follow-up may go to an orthopedic or hand clinic, where the visit may center on the bone and no one may ask about memory, sleep or concentration.

In 2024, Pinellas County recorded 14,391 crashes, 8,804 injuries and 108 deaths (FLHSMV). Seriously injured adults may be taken to Orlando Health Bayfront Hospital, the only state-accredited Level II adult trauma center in Pinellas County. Others are seen at emergency departments such as Morton Plant Hospital in Clearwater, St. Anthony's Hospital in St. Petersburg or HCA Florida Largo Hospital, where the focus is rightly on ruling out an emergency.

"They fixed my wrist. Nobody asked about my head." That gap belongs in the record.

Record details worth noticing

  • Whether any ER or follow-up note asks about the head, confusion or memory, or records only the fracture.
  • Whether the mechanism is described, such as a sudden stop, an airbag or a body hitting the door.
  • Later notes from therapists or family doctors that mention headaches, fog, poor sleep or irritability.
  • A gap between when symptoms were first mentioned and when anyone looked into them.
  • No dated, standardized measure of brain function in the weeks after the crash.

For related reading, see why a concussion can happen without losing consciousness, what a normal CT scan does and does not show, and how minor Pinellas crashes can still cause symptoms.

Courts and practice context

The entrance of the Pinellas County Courthouse at 315 Court Street in Clearwater, Florida
The Pinellas County Courthouse at 315 Court Street in Clearwater. Pasco and Pinellas counties make up Florida’s Sixth Judicial Circuit.

Under section 26.021, the Sixth Judicial Circuit is made up of Pasco and Pinellas counties. The people reading a medical record in a Sixth Circuit case may have no medical training. A record that names a possible concussion next to the fracture, dates when symptoms were first reported and describes them in clinical terms is easier for everyone to follow than one in which head symptoms appear for the first time months later. Counsel should confirm venue and any procedural questions for a specific case.

Where testing fits

Testing decisions belong to the client's treating provider. When that provider decides testing makes sense, Braintree's mobile team performs concussion and TBI testing at the provider's office in St. Petersburg, Clearwater, Largo, Pinellas Park, Palm Harbor and nearby communities, with scheduling coordinated through the provider. Results come back as physician-reviewed diagnostic reports.

Learn more about concussion and TBI testing, see mobile testing in St. Petersburg and Clearwater, or check recent local crashes on the St. Petersburg & Clearwater Crash Map. Clients can read what to expect as a patient.

If a client describes a worsening headache, repeated vomiting, weakness, slurred speech, a seizure or growing confusion, they should call 911 or go to an emergency room now. Orlando Health Bayfront Hospital in St. Petersburg is Pinellas County's only state-accredited Level II adult trauma center.

Frequently asked questions

Can someone have a concussion and a broken bone from the same crash?

Yes. In one study of 251 patients with a single limb fracture, interviews found a mild TBI at the time of the fracture in 23.5% of patients, compared with 8.8% in hospital records. Any client with symptoms after a crash should be evaluated by a medical provider.

Why would an ER chart leave out a concussion?

In one study of two emergency departments, 56% of patients who met the CDC definition of mild TBI had no mild TBI-related diagnosis in the ER record. The CDC also notes that symptoms can be overlooked by the patient, the family or the provider, and that some appear hours or days later.

Does a concussion require a direct hit to the head?

No. The CDC describes concussion as caused by a bump, blow or jolt to the head, or by a hit to the body that makes the head and brain move quickly back and forth.

Which judicial circuit covers Pinellas County?

Under section 26.021, Pasco and Pinellas counties make up Florida's Sixth Judicial Circuit. Counsel should confirm venue for a specific case.

Can Braintree test clients anywhere in Pinellas County?

When a client's treating provider decides testing makes sense, Braintree's mobile team tests at that provider's office anywhere in Pinellas County and returns physician-reviewed diagnostic reports. Scheduling is coordinated with the provider.

Sources

Photo credits: Howard Frankland Bridge traffic, by Apalapala at English Wikipedia, CC BY-SA 2.5, via Wikimedia Commons, resized. Pinellas County Courthouse, Clearwater, by Chad Davis, CC BY-SA 2.0, via Wikimedia Commons, resized.

This article is educational and is not medical or legal advice. If this is a medical emergency, call 911.

Two people shaking hands

Schedule a TBI briefing

Bring mobile concussion testing to your Florida practice. We diagnose. You treat.